What Should I Do About Billing Problems When Using HSA Money?


If you run into a billing problem or misunderstanding with a hospital or doctor's office for which you're planning to use money from your Health Savings Account (HSA), you could be in trouble.

This article will help you understand how hospital and doctor visits are different when paying with a Health Savings Account. Not better or worse, just different.

If you have an HSA, you must have health insurance. It's a requirement. However, if you are using money from your HSA, it means that you haven't hit the deductible of your policy yet.

In this particular situation, life is a bit different when it comes to resolving billing disputes with hospitals.

Insurance companies have a comprehensive system for dealing with billing disputes when they have covered a hospital stay or doctor visit. But when they haven't covered it because you are still within your deductible, that comprehensive dispute resolution system doesn't necessarily apply.

Here are some points to keep in mind when you are dealing with a hospital in a billing dispute, and you have paid with HSA money. I learned these important points when I was talking to an expert in this field named Dr. Vincent Riccardi, who is the owner of American Medical Consumer (www.medconsumer.com), a company dedicated to helping people resolve billing disputes with hospitals and doctors.

Here's what Dr. Riccardi has to say:

  • First, discuss the issue with your physician. Sometimes the problem stems from an incorrectly applied billing code and the doctor can easily change it to please the hospital and resolve the problem on the spot.
  • Negotiate in person. Especially if you just don't have the money to pay a bill, it makes the best sense to negotiate face-to-face with the person at the hospital who has the authority to reverse or reduce the charges. Hospitals would often rather be paid part of a bill than risk losing the entire bill. Be honest and forthright and you may have a good chance in negotiating a reduced fee from the hospital. This includes the situations where it was a misunderstanding on your part. It's at least worth a try.
  • Don't bother going to the State Medical Board. In most cases, they are not able to help you. This is the case with most government agencies. Even the Departments of Insurance cannot help, because this isn't an insurance problem, it is technically a fee-for-service situation.
  • Recourse to a lawyer is usually not fruitful unless there is a big amount involved. For amounts less than $5,000 (which is what most HSA-style deductibles are), a lawyer probably won't be able to help you.
  • Remember that the only things that count in negotiations like this are the things that have been written down. If a doctor mentioned something to you but didn't write it down, it probably won't help you. Get things in writing all the way through the process.
  • I think of HSAs as a way to "be your own insurance company" for the small stuff (under your deductible). That is its power. But it also means that when it comes to disputes, you also have to "be your own insurance company" and take charge of the negotiations with the hospital, just like an insurance company would. Your willingness and ability to negotiate will influence your ability to get unfair charges reversed or, at least, lessened. But it's a "do it yourself" situation, so be aware of that when you sign up for an HSA.

    Daryl Kulak is the author of the book "Health Insurance Off the Grid - A Wonderful Way to Use Alternative Medicine and Save Money on Insurance Using the New Health Savings Account (HSA)."

    The book provides a nine-step plan to get your self-employed or small business health insurance costs under control using a unique approach you won't find anywhere else. The book is available for sale as an e-Book or paperback at the Website http://www.healthoffthegrid.com







    Related News



    Singapore Insurance Report Q3 2008 Is Available Now - MarketWatch

    Singapore Insurance Report Q3 2008 Is Available Now
    MarketWatch -7 hours ago
    Our Singapore Insurance Report provides independent forecasts and competitive intelligence on Singapore's insurance industry. In Q308, the key change is ...
    Research and Markets: Slovenia Insurance Report Q3 2008 - In 2007 ...MarketWatch
    all 36 news articles

    Insurance Exchange Is a Good Idea - New York Times

    New York Times

    Insurance Exchange Is a Good Idea
    New York Times, United States -4 hours ago
    By Ezekiel Emanuel In this installment of Health Care Watch, Stuart M. Butler and Ezekiel Emanuel talk about what the candidates are saying about insurance...
    Editors: Healthy Line of AttackNational Review Online
    National panelists debate health careBizjournals.com
    Two Ways to Extend Health InsuranceKiplinger.com
    Dallas Morning News - Wall Street Journal
    all 1,452 news articles

    Group still owns Fortis Insurance - Malaysia Star

    The Associated Press

    Group still owns Fortis Insurance
    Malaysia Star, Malaysia -Oct 6, 2008
    PETALING JAYA: Fortis Group has confirmed its continued ownership of 100% participation in Fortis Insurance International NV, following the recent ...
    Ping An to post huge losses due to investment in FortisPress Trust of India
    China's Ping An Insurance to book 15.7 bln yuan loss from Fortis ...Forbes
    Ping An may lose 2b yuan on Fortis investmentChina Daily
    Financial Times - The Associated Press
    all 200 news articles

    Narragansett Bay Insurance Company Succeeds to Adirondack ... - MarketWatch

    Narragansett Bay Insurance Company Succeeds to Adirondack ...
    MarketWatch -10 hours ago
    PAWTUCKET, RI, Oct 07, 2008 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- Narragansett Bay Insurance Company announced that it has entered into a renewal rights agreement with ...
    Renewal Rights Agreement Bolsters Narragansett Bay in New YorkInsurance Journal
    all 8 news articles


    Gina Russo Opens Trenchant Insurance in Las Vegas - MarketWatch

    Gina Russo Opens Trenchant Insurance in Las Vegas
    MarketWatch -9 hours ago
    LAS VEGAS, Oct 07, 2008 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- Gina Russo opened the Trenchant Insurance Company at 8778 S. Maryland Parkway, Suite 105 in Las Vegas. ...

    FDIC approves bank fee increase for insurance fund - BusinessWeek

    CBS News

    FDIC approves bank fee increase for insurance fund
    BusinessWeek -5 hours ago
    Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. Chairman Sheila Bair made the proposal -- which will raise the average insurance premiums paid by banks and thrifts to 13.5 ...
    FDIC Proposes Doubling Fees to Boost Insurance Fund (Update3)Bloomberg
    FDIC chair seeks higher bank fees to boost deposit insurance fund ...International Herald Tribune
    Ahead of the Bell: FDIC mulls bank insurance feesForbes
    Los Angeles Times - Wall Street Journal Blogs
    all 1,255 news articles

    Crisis strengthens Manulife's hand in AIG bid - Globe and Mail

    Boston Globe

    Crisis strengthens Manulife's hand in AIG bid
    Globe and Mail, Canada -16 hours ago
    The American insurance giant is under pressure to sell businesses quickly to repay an $85-billion (US) Federal Reserve loan that spared it from bankruptcy ...
    HSBC Life Launches Online Insurance Sales In TaiwanEasyBourse.com
    Insurance giant granted lifelineThe Press Association
    Expect Bermuda insurers to eye AIG targetsRoyal Gazette
    Belfast Telegraph - Forbes
    all 913 news articles

    Grange Insurance Welcomed As FHLBank Cincinnati Member - MarketWatch

    Grange Insurance Welcomed As FHLBank Cincinnati Member
    MarketWatch -10 hours ago
    CINCINNATI, Oct 7, 2008 (GlobeNewswire via COMTEX) -- Grange Insurance (Grange) has been approved for membership at the Federal Home Loan Bank of Cincinnati ...

    Insurance Professionals See Investor Confidence of Retirement ... - MarketWatch

    Insurance Professionals See Investor Confidence of Retirement ...
    MarketWatch -8 hours ago
    The survey of more than 300 insurance industry professionals was conducted via instant electronic polling. Chief among the survey findings are: "A central ...

    SeaBright Insurance Holdings to Release 2008 Third Quarter Results ... - WELT ONLINE

    SeaBright Insurance Holdings to Release 2008 Third Quarter Results ...
    WELT ONLINE, Germany -2 hours ago
    SeaBright Insurance Holdings, Inc. (Nasdaq:SEAB) announced today that it plans to release financial results for the third quarter ended September 30, 2008, ...